Saturn Sky Forums: Saturn Sky Forum - Reply to Topic
General Saturn Sky Discussion Forum for discussing general topics on the Saturn SKY.

Thread: Installed new speakers now it sound like crap! Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Trackback:
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :

Register Now



In order to be able to post messages on the Saturn Sky Forums: Saturn Sky Forum forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:
OR

Log-in










  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
08-17-2019 02:21 PM
JohnWR
Quote:
Originally Posted by stungjoe View Post
UPDATE: Speaker selection was the key here. I used the Kenwood KFC-1666s two way speakers based upon the fitment guide at Crutchfield. Let me tell ya, fitting is one thing being a better fit is another. I swapped those out for a set of Infinity REF6520CX 2-Way Component System and only used the woofers (for now). I reckon the two way Kenwoods were just adding too much treble since I already have the tweeters in the door sill. The ohms rating got a little bit closer at 3 ohms for the Infinity to the factory 2 ohms. I also suspect the Infinity is just a better speaker. It does appear the Infinity's have more surface area than the KW's have also.

Sound is SO much better now!
That is good news. Glad you got it worked out, and told us about it!
08-17-2019 10:57 AM
stungjoe
Quote:
Originally Posted by idle-mind View Post
Did your speakers fit directly into the space where the factory speakers came from, or did you have to use an adapter for fitment?
Yes a direct fit. I just started all four screws first then tightened them up. There is a newer version of this speaker (6530 vs my 6520's) but Amazon had last year's model (6520) at almost half the cost.
08-17-2019 10:52 AM
idle-mind Did your speakers fit directly into the space where the factory speakers came from, or did you have to use an adapter for fitment?
08-17-2019 10:21 AM
stungjoe UPDATE: Speaker selection was the key here. I used the Kenwood KFC-1666s two way speakers based upon the fitment guide at Crutchfield. Let me tell ya, fitting is one thing being a better fit is another. I swapped those out for a set of Infinity REF6520CX 2-Way Component System and only used the woofers (for now). I reckon the two way Kenwoods were just adding too much treble since I already have the tweeters in the door sill. The ohms rating got a little bit closer at 3 ohms for the Infinity to the factory 2 ohms. I also suspect the Infinity is just a better speaker. It does appear the Infinity's have more surface area than the KW's have also.

Sound is SO much better now!
07-17-2019 05:12 PM
JohnWR
Quote:
Originally Posted by stungjoe View Post
........Those days are over for this ol' man!
While it is true that "If its too loud you are too old", it is also true that old ears may not realize how loud it is!
Years of race engines, guns, and rock music make things sound different than they probably should.
07-17-2019 05:05 PM
stungjoe
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnWR View Post
Fading to the rear would balance the sound and drastically reduce the power to the fronts, so maybe over-driving isn't a concern.
My next step when I go get my RKSport spoiler installed at the body shop this Friday. For now it's back under the cover and the carport.



Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnWR View Post
The key seems to be setting the amp parameters to match the actual speakers, and then not turning the volume up "Too high".
Those days are over for this ol' man!
07-17-2019 04:59 PM
JohnWR
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nova-Exarch View Post
See? This is why I hoped more knowledgeable people would chime in.

Curious though... Can he even push 4x the power into the rears when they are max RMS 25W (compared to the doors max RMS 300W)?
Dangerously more knowledgeable, maybe, because I'm not sure I am interpreting things correctly. Sometimes I look at them backwards.

The amp is rated at 50W max for 4 channels, but 22W per channel at full bandwidth, which matches well with the SO rears.
The Kenwood fronts are rated at 300W peak, but 30W RMS, so you can overdrive them with the 50W amp, which should be rated RMS.

The issue arises if you have balance and fade set to neutral, the fronts are going to be 4x as loud due to their better sensitivity (90dB vs 84).
Fading to the rear would balance the sound and drastically reduce the power to the fronts, so maybe over-driving isn't a concern.

The key seems to be setting the amp parameters to match the actual speakers, and then not turning the volume up "Too high".
My experience has been that you are more likely to get distortion when the amp is underpowered for the speakers rather than the other way.
07-17-2019 04:26 PM
Nova-Exarch
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnWR View Post
Glad you are on track to sort this out.

Actually, looking at the speaker ratings, the door speakers are giving you four times the sound level as the rears at the same power, so you may be over-driving them.
The Kenwoods are rated at 90 dB, but the SOs are only 84 dB, so it will take four times as much power to get the same volume out of them.

And yes, less than half the power and an open cockpit will combine to give you a lot less sound at well as lower sound quality.
See? This is why I hoped more knowledgeable people would chime in.

Curious though... Can he even push 4x the power into the rears when they are max RMS 25W (compared to the doors max RMS 300W)?
07-17-2019 04:10 PM
JohnWR Glad you are on track to sort this out.

Actually, looking at the speaker ratings, the door speakers are giving you four times the sound level as the rears at the same power, so you may be over-driving them.
The Kenwoods are rated at 90 dB, but the SOs are only 84 dB, so it will take four times as much power to get the same volume out of them.

And yes, less than half the power and an open cockpit will combine to give you a lot less sound at well as lower sound quality.
07-17-2019 03:11 PM
stungjoe
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nova-Exarch View Post

I think you have two issues here:
1. The door speakers are not getting enough power to have the punch you want.
2. The rears are under rated and when you crank it up to push the doors you're exceeding their sweet spot.
I think changing the speaker configuration at the head unit helped a whole bunch. They were set on 8" for the doors. I changed them to 5 1/4" and the sound improved. I also set the rear speakers to (I think) 3" from the selections available and they also changed for the better. I just think I need to fine tune a few more parameters on the head unit to match my speaker selection and personal preference. I already have dramatically more bass coming from the door speakers now.

It could also be that I am spoiled from the 9 speaker 500 watt stereo in my Grand Cherokee..haha
07-17-2019 02:49 PM
Nova-Exarch
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnWR View Post
The Monsoon system has an amp.
Not familiar with his adapter kit, but some of those bypass factory wiring entirely. He did say the speakers were moving though, lol.

I had that problem with my son's 99 expy when I went to add an aftermarket system. Installing the harness cut out the factory system's amp. Was seriously annoying to deal with. Especially considering my father-in-law (the primary driver at the time) had like 60-70% hearing loss. I just restored it to stock.
07-17-2019 02:44 PM
Nova-Exarch It's also worth considering that different speakers have different resistance levels and whatnot (sorry, I don't have any more technical words... maybe TS or other electrical gurus can chime in)

Short version: Stock speakers are matched to the power output of the factory system. Just popping in higher wattage speakers doesn't mean you can crank the system up to full volume and get "better" sound. You might get "louder" sound but if the head unit starts distorting as it's pushing its maximum power... you end up with ****ty sound.

Attempt with numbers: Say your stock radio is rated for 50W and can go as high as 40-45W before distorting. That's mated up to 60W speakers (if yer lucky) just to cover the max power and prevent owners all over from blowing out speakers. With that setup, it starts to sound like crap at volume 18-20 (our of 20) so people mistakenly pop in 150W speakers assuming the speakers are the limiting factor. The factory unit is maxed while the speakers aren't even close to being in their sweet spot.

But... from reading your last post, I dunno that this is the cause for your disliking the sound.

The internet says your head unit is Max power output: 50 watts max. The door speakers say: Nominal Output Power 30 Watt, Max (RMS) Output Power 300 Watt. And the rears... Minimum RMS Wattage 2 Maximum RMS Wattage 25 Peak Power Handling (Watts) 50.

I think you have two issues here:
1. The door speakers are not getting enough power to have the punch you want.
2. The rears are under rated and when you crank it up to push the doors you're exceeding their sweet spot.

--

However... I am NOT a pro by any means! Likely, neither are most of the jackasses at Best Buy or Car Pros If you want truly amazing sound look on Yelp for a smaller pro sound shop. They'll cost more, but sometimes you get what you pay for xD

I hope some of the more experienced/knowledgeable folks can correct me if I'm wayyy off base.
07-17-2019 02:08 PM
stungjoe I finally got around to taking the door panel off and according to this diagram the dark green wire on the passenger side is for ground. That's the way it was wired using the adapter.

Now for the (I think) embarrassing part. There are so many fine tuning options (speaker size, location, cross-over points, cabin size...etc) that I had not played with. I sat and made the coarse adjustments and some fine tuning for preference (EQ, bass boost...yadda yadda) that I have it sounding very decent for now. It's funny how different sources (Android Auto, bluetooth, radio, USB) have different characteristics but I think I am on my way.

Thanks again for the help.
07-02-2019 03:22 PM
stungjoe Thanks for all of the replies. I plan on swapping the pins in the connector like I did on the Jeep because the speaker's ends are big guy/little guy and can't be swapped.
07-02-2019 12:34 PM
Knight
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnWR View Post
Switching the polarity will put the sound out of phase and could easily result in poor bass response. If left and right are phased differently you will also get odd sound imaging with a number of characteristics. It would be worth it to make sure you have both sides the same, just in case.

The first and probably easiest thing to do is to reverse the speaker wires. I would do the doors first and then the rears, since the doors seem to have the better bass response. Definitely don't do all four at the same time since that could confuse the results. If the sound gets better after the doors are switched do the rears and see what that change is since it is possible that one set is correct.
I agree; the description of what he is hearing after adding the new speakers sounds like there is a polarity / out of phase issue.
This thread has more than 15 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome